An Open Letter To OFSTED And The Education Secretary
Ella Marshall’s impassioned, emotional open letter to the chief inspector of OFSTED and the education secretary.
I have watched many of my previously buoyant close friends sink into a pit of self-loathing and misery.
Dear Sir Michael Wilshaw and Mrs Nicola Morgan,
This year, I have watched many of my previously buoyant close friends sink into a pit of self-loathing and misery. This year, I have witnessed many of my parents drift away from any kind of comfort in the profession that once anchored, enthused and fulfilled them. I am, of course, not talking of my biological parents but my guardians of English Literature, History, Philosophy and Spanish. My AS Level teachers, and the wider school community, a limp and dying reef, saturated with desperation, despondency and dejection.
Mr Wilshaw, on 14th April you said that you ‘take reports of low morale amongst teachers with a barrel of salt’ and you appeared to blame it entirely on ‘bad pay’. I understand. When you receive a £200,000 salary it’s probably very easy to think that all those who work in education are motivated by money. You are one of Britain’s highest paid public sector workers and yet teachers are being held accountable for the failure of the education system. With recent reforms to examination methods, the curriculum and the independence of schools, the whole culture of education has been reformed to one that reduces bright human beings to marks, grades and marginal gains. Teachers and students alike are forced to work into the early hours of the morning to hit deadlines. Allocating time for a ‘social’ life is effectively allocating a period of time whereby you will try to relax but feel overwhelmingly guilty that you are not sat at a desk completing one of 20 or so tasks that are on your ‘to-do list’.
I implore you to try and understand the realities of education reforms being pushed through by your government.
Mrs Morgan, I implore you to try and understand the realities of education reforms being pushed through by your government. Take the example of coursework. Due to greater emphasis on linear examination, we spend the first 18 years of our lives learning ‘exam technique’ rather than how to produce good quality work in time for deadlines, as we are most likely going to be required to do so in our professions.
No leading academics, business leaders and/or researchers are expected to write essays and reports in 37 minutes. Yet this is how long I have to thematically analyse the whole of Elizabeth I’s reign. I have 45 minutes to compare and contrast two 200 page books and 30 minutes to explain and evaluate philosophical arguments that stretch back thousands of years. Strenuous exam conditions are not a reflection of the workplace or any aspect of life outside of the education system.
Moreover, the academisation of our schools has effectively forced them to function like businesses, rather than as a public service. My school recently had to scrap one of two (constantly oversubscribed) school counsellors to employ a business manager. The shrinking pastoral care and over-emphasis on exams in our education system is contributing to increasing mental health issues amongst students and teachers alike.
A few years ago, I found it impossible to deal with assessment situations but I was lucky to have a teacher who helped me recover from that place and push me to achieve two A*s in English GCSEs. She recently left the teaching profession because she could not bear to put us through a system that she wholeheartedly disagreed with, one that fosters low self esteem. The recent emphasis on science over arts has created a divide between two areas of study that work best when they are combined and compliment one another. Creative students feel undervalued and unable to succeed, whereas those who take STEM subjects are made to feel as though it’s futile to pursue the arts at all.
If teachers were to strike, many of us students would be on the picket line with them…
If teachers were to strike, many of us students would be on the picket line with them, regardless of any hours lost in the classroom. Time spent doing schoolwork can very easily feel like time wasted anyway – it’s hard to feel any satisfaction when all you receive out of years of tears and graft is a few letters on a piece of paper. We are conditioned to believe that anything less than an A or B is a failure. It doesn’t feel like you’re living during your time in the education system, merely existing to gain a few marks here and there. How do I know that it is worse now than it has ever been before? I remember primary school as a blissful discovery of the world but my primary-school age younger brother recently cried to me because being in the classroom made him feel inadequate.
Mr Wilshaw and Mrs Morgan, I sincerely hope that you do not rest easy at night when the servants of your system lie awake toiling and panicking over what extra workload tomorrow may bring.
A sixth form student who has had enough
What do you think?
What do you think? Is the education system working for you? Think the government have our best interests at heart? We really want to know your thoughts on this. Should we be learning more life skills? Should school subjects have a real world context?
(all opinions expressed are those of the author and do not reflect the opinions of Rife magazine.)
Support more young people to have their voices heard
Rife is Watershed‘s online magazine created for young people, by young people.
We offer paid internships and publish work by young writers, photographers, illustrators, and filmmakers from all sorts of backgrounds, helping them get into creative careers. Rife has reached over 8,000 young people through our workshops, over 220 young people have made stuff for Rife on topics ranging from mental health to identity to baked beans, and last year, over 200,000 people visited our website.
In these complex and uncertain times hearing from and supporting young people who are advocating for social change and contributing fresh perspectives has never been so important.
Through supporting Rife you can ensure that this important work continues and that more young people have their voices heard.